Skip to main content
25% off questionnaires, plus a free year of membership for new and monthly members (renews unless you cancel)60% off a first year of annual membership (renews at the annual rate unless you cancel)Opens the offers page, with each offer’s details and terms.
Clarity4Couples
Sign inSign up

What should you think through before opening up your relationship?

An open or non-monogamous relationship is a different way to structure a partnership, not a more or less evolved one. Some couples find it suits them well and others find it does not. Before changing anything, be clear on why each of you wants this, check that the agreement is genuine rather than one person going along to keep the other, and set out specific agreements about what is and is not okay. Expect jealousy, and agree from the start that either of you can say no, or ask to pause or stop.

Last reviewed

Why each of you wants it

People come to this for different reasons. For some it is curiosity. For others it reflects something they have known about themselves for a long time, and a closed relationship has always felt like a poor fit. Both of those are reasons about what you want to add to your life.

A different reason is trying to fix something: a long dry spell, a sense of drifting apart, one partner's restlessness. Opening a relationship to solve a problem inside it can make the problem bigger, because new connections draw on the same time, attention and trust that were already stretched thin. It is worth naming your reasons honestly to each other, including the uncomfortable ones.

Real agreement, or going along

A yes given to avoid losing someone is not really agreement. It can feel generous at the time and turn into quiet resentment later. Ask yourself whether you would choose this if the relationship were not at stake, and ask your partner the same.

Take time over the decision and talk about it more than once. Notice whether one of you is mostly persuading while the other is mostly conceding. An arrangement you both actually want stands a much better chance than one only one of you does. If your partner says they cannot stay in a closed relationship, that is an honest statement of a difference. It may mean you want different things, and agreeing only to keep them is the trap above.

Agreements worth making

Vague rules tend to break at the first real test, so specific ones help. Decide what is and is not okay, with whom and where, and how you will look after sexual health, including testing and protection. Talk about what you each want to hear about other connections and what you would rather not know. Then agree on time, such as which nights stay yours, and on who else, if anyone, will know about the arrangement. Anyone either of you sees should know about it before anything starts.

Treat the first version as a draft. Set a date to revisit it after a few weeks, and again later, because what sounded fine in theory often feels different in practice.

Plan for jealousy

Jealousy will very likely show up, even for people who expected not to feel it. That does not prove the arrangement is a mistake. It is information, and it is easier to handle if you have agreed in advance what you will do when it arrives: say so early, without blame, and talk about what would help.

For some people the jealousy settles with time and reassurance. For others it points at something the agreements do not yet cover. Either way it is a shared problem to work through, not a failing in the person feeling it.

Either of you can stop

Any agreement to open a relationship should include the right to change your mind. Either of you can say no at the start, ask to slow down, pause for a while, or end the arrangement entirely, and that request deserves to be taken seriously rather than argued away.

It also helps to agree how a pause would work in practice, so that asking for one does not feel like a crisis. If the conversation keeps going in circles, or one of you feels unheard, a counselor or therapist who works with non-monogamous relationships can help you think it through together.

If you want to go further

  • Jealousy Quiz

    A short, free quiz on your own pattern of jealousy: what sets it off, what helps it settle and what you tend to do while it is there. It is about you rather than your partner, and needs no account.

  • Trust Quiz

    A short, free quiz on trust in one specific relationship: whether your partner follows through, whether you feel you are getting the full picture, and whether trust holds up through a real argument, all things an open arrangement leans on.

A note on safety

If you are being pushed into sex with other people, threatened, or afraid of how your partner will react if you say no, that is coercion, not an agreement. RAINN's National Sexual Assault Hotline is 1-800-656-4673 or rainn.org, and the National Domestic Violence Hotline is 1-800-799-7233 or thehotline.org.

This guide is for reflection and general information. It is not a diagnosis, and it is not a substitute for talking with a licensed professional.